Showing posts with label A* Blogger Scott S. Show all posts
Showing posts with label A* Blogger Scott S. Show all posts

Saturday, December 15, 2012

NY FLYERS 2012 TOYS FOR TOTS RUN

Scott S
The Flyers annual Toys for Tots Run is one of many longstanding Flyer traditions. For years Sandy A arranged the toy drive to benefit children with serious illnesses staying in the Pediatric Center at Mt. Sinai Hospital on Manhattan’s Upper East Side. Participants would typically gather at the Engineers’ Gate, put their donated toys in Jerry F’s car, run down Central Park’s East Drive, exit the Park, stroll past the holiday windows on Fifth Avenue, and sing holiday songs underneath the Rockefeller Center Christmas tree with Laurent N conducting. Then the singers would run north through Central Park to Mt. Sinai, go room to room singing for the appreciative children (and their parents) and distribute toys as they sang.  The event concluded with a celebratory holiday brunch.

This Year's Singer's Show Off Their Dance Moves, Too!
Several years ago, for the sake of the health of both the patients and the singers, Mt. Sinai forbade the Flyer choir’s singing in the children’s rooms. Instead, the Flyers were ushered into the hospital’s new internal television studio, where the singers would perform live for approximately half an hour. Children were able to call in with their requests, which inevitably were dominated by songs the Flyers had just sung, songs the Flyers didn’t know, or everyone’s favorite musical tribute to holiday sadism “Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer.” Thankfully, the mellifluous bagpipe stylings of Flyer Patrick D kept the singers’ holiday spirits bright.

Unfortunately, the toy drive was canceled in 2011 when the Flyers and the Mt. Sinai staff could not agree on a suitable time for a visit (“could you come in at 6:30pm on the third Sunday in December?”) However, this venerable Flyers’ holiday tradition returned this year thanks to Sandy A’s tireless efforts. She arranged a toy drive to benefit kids affected by the recent Hurricane Sandy and coordinated with the Central Park Zoo to accept the donated toys (no, we didn’t sing for the animals). As an added benefit, those who gave toys were given a ticket good for future admission to the Bronx Zoo (note: Sandy also volunteers as a guide at the zoo, so be on the lookout for a Flyer day at the zoo in 2013!).

Jodie F, Laurent N, Laurie H (with her dog Paco), Steve K, Debbie P, Robert B, Scott S, Amy S, Jennifer B, David W
The Flyer singers met near the Central Park Zoo entrance at the appointed time – this year’s participants included Sandy A, Jennifer B, Robert B, Maribeth C, Jodie F, Laurie H and her dog Paco, Laurent N, Steve K, Debbie P, Amy S, Scott S, and David W. After introducing ourselves to each other and posing for some group photos, the singers dropped off their toys at the Central Park Zoo, then headed out of the Park and down Fifth Avenue to see the 2012 holiday windows.

Laurent was waiting for us underneath the Rock Center tree when we arrived, but as has been the case the last several times the event has been held, our group was prevented from singing directly underneath the tree by the Center’s crack security force. Apparently, there’s now a formal sign-up process in place for groups wishing to perform underneath the tree, and groups that attempt to circumvent this process are threatened with eviction, incarceration, and forcible removal of vocal cords with a sharp instrument (my apologies to any junior Flyers who may be reading this). After posing for several group photos underneath the tree, we found an unguarded area across the street and belted out several up-tempo holiday favorites before the wind and steady rain conspired to dampen our spirits.

Click the Arrrow:
Then Sing Along with The Von Flyer Family Singers

The group had planned to return to Central Park and enjoy a four-mile run together, but due to the weather the group decided to forego the run and proceed directly to the brunch portion of our program. After securing a table for twelve at a café in the Rock Center concourse, the group decided to leave after discovering that the cafe didn’t see fit to include brunch items on its menu.

Brunchtime for Hungry Singers
A new venue was chosen, brunch was ordered, and a good time was had by all. Thanks again to the hearty souls who chose to participate this year, and special thanks, as always, to Sandy for organizing the event and Laurent for leading us in song!

-Scott S

Read more...

Monday, January 3, 2011

Boston, Women, and Qualifying Times

Scott S.
With registration for the 2011 Boston Marathon closing out in record time there's been a fair amount of discussion among Flyers and other runners lately that the Boston qualifying times should be changed. Specifically, many have voiced the opinion that the traditional 30-minute gap between the male and female qualifying standards for each age group is “too much”. The elite women finish much less than 30 minutes behind the elite men – doesn’t that prove that the gap is too much?

No, it doesn’t. In order to draw any meaningful conclusions about Boston qualifying times, you must consider a much larger sample than the handful of men capable of running a sub-2:10 marathon and the handful of women capable of running a sub-2:30 marathon. One way to do this is to analyze age group results for a sufficiently large population of both male and female runners.

Paula Radclife and Haile Gebrselassie: Elite men's and women's times are getting closer, but that doesn't mean BQ times should be the same.
I chose the 2010 NYC Marathon, which had 29,000+ male finishers and 16,000+ female finishers for this analysis. For each age group that had a reasonably large sample of finishers I looked at the times for male and female finishers in the 10th, 25th, 50th, 75th, and 90th percentiles. Here is a summary of my results:

First, let's look at the breakdown of finishers, just for reference:

Total Number of 2010 NYC Marathon Finishers by Age Group and Gender
Age Group
#Male
#Female
#Total
20-24
699
575
1,274
25-29
2,477
2,639
5,116
30-34
3,857
2,887
6,744
35-39
5,000
2,794
7,794
40-44
5,761
2,801
8,562
45-49
4,289
2,037
6,326
50-54
3,448
1,356
4,804
55-59
1,647
594
2,241
60-64
1,051
271
1,322

Now let's break it down further, looking at the men's finishing times first:

Men’s Finishing Times by Age Group & Percentile
(Faster time corresponds to lower percentile)
Age Group
10%
25%
50%
75%
90%
20-24
3:21:04
3:42:11
4:11:53
4:41:24
5:20:21
25-29
3:11:38
3:38:30
4:03:00
4:37:39
5:14:29
30-34
3:16:34
3:39:52
4:06:19
4:39:15
5:12:12
35-39
3:18:53
3:40:07
4:05:45
4:38:44
5:11:38
40-44
3:17:55
3:39:19
4:05:35
4:36:57
5:13:07
45-49
3:22:03
3:44:09
4:10:22
4:43:09
5:17:20
50-54
3:27:39
3:48:12
4:16:13
4:49:14
5:27:10
55-59
3:39:49
4:00:32
4:32:05
5:07:45
5:44:31
60-64
3:47:06
4:09:48
4:42:22
5:23:52
6:09:51

Now compare the above chart to this one for the women:

Women’s Finishing Times by Age Group & Percentile
(Faster time corresponds to lower percentile)
Age Group
10%
25%
50%
75%
90%
20-24
3:42:39
4:06:51
4:33:31
5:07:20
5:49:04
25-29
3:41:25
4:02:22
4:29:01
5:02:35
5:36:48
30-34
3:41:37
4:04:14
4:31:28
5:05:58
5:44:39
35-39
3:45:26
4:08:07
4:35:15
5:07:58
5:46:48
40-44
3:43:49
4:05:20
4:34:49
5:09:01
5:48:26
45-49
3:46:09
4:09:30
4:41:31
5:;16:28
5:55:45
50-54
3:58:03
4:22:17
4:51:35
5:29:37
6:10:34
55-59
4:08:42
4:36:17
5:05:51
5:49:15
6:32:54
60-64
4:17:35
4:44:07
5:24:53
6:09:51
6:47:54

Now, let's refresh your memory regarding Boston Qualifying times:

Current Boston Marathon
Qualifying Standards
(by Age Group and Gender)
Age Group
Men
Women
< 35
3:10
3:40
35-39
3:15
3:45
40-44
3:20
3:50
45-49
3:30
4:00
50-54
3:35
4:05
55-59
3:45
4:15
60-64
4:00
4:30

Here are the two things that strike me when reviewing these results:
1. The 30-minute gap between men and women at the 10% percentile (roughly the cut-off for qualifying for Boston) appears to be justified. Perhaps one could argue for lowering the gap to 25 minutes for the age groups up to 45-49, but I doubt the Boston Athletic Association would want to explain having different gaps for different age groups.
2. The drop-off in qualifying standards across age-group bands is too rapid. The major drop-off in times occurs in the 50-54 band, not the 45-49 band.

Here’s what I would propose as an alternative, with the revisions in red:

Proposed Boston Marathon
Qualifying Standards
(by Age Group and Gender)
Age Group
Men
Women
< 30


3:10
3:40
30-34
3:15
3:45
35-39
3:15
3:45
40-44
3:15
3:45
45-49
3:20
3:50
50-54
3:30
4:00
55-59
3:40
4:10
60-64
3:50
4:20

I realize this proposal is based on the results of just one race in a given year, but since the NYC Marathon has a significant number of finishers in most age groups and is slightly more difficult than the other major Fall marathons, it’s a good starting point (note: I did a similar analysis ~5 years ago for the Flyers newsletter, and if anything, NYC should now be “easier” given the implementation of the wave start in 2009, which I’m guessing more than offsets the now larger field).

What strikes you looking at these results? - Scott S. (The Numbers Runner)


Blogmaster's Note: Along with being our beloved Numbers Runner, Scott is also known across the web for his Sherpa websites: Sherpa Social Media, Fantasy Football and Fantasy Baseball. Check them out and let him show you the way!

Read more...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP